Cadillac Seville (1998 - 2002)
BY ANDY ENRIGHT
As you ascend the pricing scale, there comes a point when a cars ability becomes largely taken for granted and what the car says about you becomes more important. This is a problem that has haunted the Cadillac Seville STS. The American giant has put so many toes in the water of the shark-infested European luxury car market that youd expect it to nursing some rather nasty wounds. In 1998 however, Cadillac came back in a bigger way than ever before with the Seville.
Theres no doubt its a good car, but then so is a Nissan QX or a Toyota Camry and would you really want to be seen stepping out of one of these at the golf club? Image talks and a used Cadillac Seville may well prove what many suspected talk is cheap.
| Build |  |
| Comfort |  |
| Depreciation |  |
| Economy |  |
| Equipment | |
| Handling | |
| Insurance | |
| Performance |  |
| Styling |  |
| Value | |
Can it really steal sales from the established players? The StabiliTrak drive dynamics system, tweaked since the Seville first arrived here, might just help. This is an active handling system intended, with traction control, to harness the 305bhp of the 4.6-litre Northstar V8 - the only engine on offer and now fitted with redesigned cylinder heads developed mainly to meet ever-tougher emissions regulations in both the USA and Europe. For the money you'd expect driver aids like this. BMW and Mercedes already offer stability systems that in extreme situations throttle the car back whilst simultaneously applying the brakes, hopefully helping the driver regain control when things get tricky. As you'd expect from a car pitched in size and price against Jaguar's XJ8 Sovereign 4.0, BMW's 540i and Mercedes' E430, the Cadillac comes impressively equipped. The Bose 4.0 stereo system is billed as the world's most advanced - and sounds it. There's also dual-zone climate control, leather upholstery, heated seats front and rear (!) plus an electrically adjustable steering wheel. The adaptive seating system inflates and deflates a series of ten air cushions to give a precisely tailored seat fit. Some of the detailing is quite interesting too. Like steering wheel controls not only for the stereo but also for the air conditioning (why has no one thought of that before?) Of more dubious value is the digital compass built into the rear view mirror.
Twin front and side airbags also come as part of the deal, as does the latest Bosch ABS system and a 4-speed automatic gearbox (there's no manual option).
The Seville STS hasnt been the catastrophic money pit that had been predicted by industry doom-mongerers. Not quite. No, it hasnt performed as strongly in the used arena as an equivalent Mercedes, BMW or Audi, but its residual values have surprised many who predicted two-year-old Sevilles to be beer-money barges. Whilst buying a new Seville STS cant be described as financial suicide, its probably fair to describe it as malicious self-wounding with a blunt implement.
A 1998 R-registered Seville STS is worth around £6,700, or a fraction of its new value of £39,750. A 1999 S-registered model is worth a little more about £7,400 being a fair price. With newer models youre looking at around £8,500 for a 2000 V-plate with 2001 51-reg examples currently changing hands at about £10,700. Many Seville owners discovered the harsh realities of life with a new Caddy that the cars value plummeted by 25% as soon as they drove it off the forecourt.
Despite its excellent safety record, insurance for the STS is a punishing Group 19.
The Seville is an astonishingly reliable car. With service intervals every 100,000-mile, the General Motors dealer network have no significant faults to report. When checking over a Seville look for damage to trim or minor body imperfections. In this sector of the market, such damage knocks used values hard.
Your best bet will be to bag a low mileage used car from one of the approved dealers.
(approx based on a 2000 Seville STS) Whilst it would be easy to assume that for such a low volume model spares prices would be punitively expensive, thats not really the case. If you were figuring that the General Motors parts would be Vauxhall-cheap, then youd be labouring under a similar misapprehension. Prices are on a par with class rivals. A radiator will cost around £515, an alternator just over £400 and a starter motor around £150.
Front brake pads are approximately £75 a pair whilst a front headlamp costs in the region of £260.
What the StabiliTrak stability control system has done to the Seville is to refine the concept, both by making its activation smoother and enabling the driver to power more easily out of dangerous manoeuvres. In its latest incarnation it has more heart-stopping scenarios programmed in to its electronic brain and reacts in more innovative ways to a drivers mistakes. Easy to say, harder to prove. A violent last minute lane-switch on soaking tarmac at 55mph pitches the car into a lurid sideways slide so easy to correct that you feel like Mario Andretti.
Only when you do the same test with the system deactivated do you realise how small a chance you would have of avoiding an accident in an ordinary car. StabiliTrak is an integral part of the STS Seville specification. The STS tag stands for 'Seville Touring Sedan; a title intended to indicate the car's handling aspirations as a BMW 5 Series competitor. Many European buyers are going to take issue with that because, on a short run at least, the big Caddy feels anything but a BMW. Clearly, the Detroit engineers have listened carefully to early European criticism. The steering, noted for being too light, now has what the boffins call "active steering effort compensation" to increase turning effort and give more feel through the steering wheel when the front wheels break traction. Better, yes, but most still would say that the driving experience is still not as involving as when piloting the German car. You might also think that the ride is too springy after a trip round the block. Find some more challenging roads, however, and a very different picture emerges.
Above 50mph, the speed-sensitive steering begins to come into its own, as does the ride. Not that you'd believe you were in anything German, or even in a Jaguar come to that. But this feeling is deceptive. The Seville has the most absorbent ride in its class and achieves it without resorting to a suspension set-up which has more in common with a waterbed. Over dips and humps that would have an E-Class or a 5 Series taking off or smashing on its bump stops, the Cadillac cruises serenely.
Don't get us wrong. Unlike say, a 540i, it's not a car youd take for a country lane blast just for the heck of it, but over fast, undulating A or B roads, it's the most cosseting of all. The magnificent Northstar V8 engine struggles to deploy its power cleanly through the front wheels, but is still the Sevilles best feature. A limp-home feature allows the car to run safely for up to 50 miles, even after total loss of oil. Service intervals of 100,000 miles should suggest that its not a temperamental unit either.
The Seville STS makes an interesting used buy if youre after something outside the mainstream Audi-BMW-Mercedes axis. It rarely feels as accomplished as its German rivals, but its a cheaper used bet and youll never feel like youre going with the herd. Pursue an older model and let the previous owner swallow the cost of depreciation. With 100,000-mile service intervals and surprisingly good fuel economy, buying used is an economical way of getting behind the wheel of this generous slice of American pie.
