The best and worst cars to own 2013

This new survey of more than 110 different cars has worked out definitively which are the best and worst to own.

Each year, What Car? magazine joins forces with market researchers at US firm JD Power and Associates to produce a wide-ranging survey of drivers' satisfaction with their cars.

This year, JD Power surveyed 16,000 UK car motorists, who together own 116 different models of car aged between one and three years old. Owners rated their cars on 66 criteria, which were then combined to deliver an overall score. Points given for reliability, performance, servicing and running costs are shown as a final percentage score.

Only models with over 4,000 sales and at least 50 completed online surveys were eligible for inclusion in the 2013 report. Together, these motorists had driven more than 340 million miles in their vehicles.

[The cheapest and most expensive places to buy petrol]


The ten worst cars to own

Let's take a look at this year's results, starting with the ten cars that fared worst in JD Power's survey. Here are the worst clunkers to own and drive:

Ranking

Car model

Percentage

score

116

Chevrolet Spark

70.2%

115

Alfa Romeo MiTo

70.7%

114

Fiat Grande Punto/Punto Evo

72.0%

113

Ford Ka

72.2%

112

Fiat Panda

73.7%

111

Peugeot 107

73.9%

108=

Citroën C5

74.1%

108=

BMW X1

74.1%

108=

Alfa Romeo Giulietta

74.1%

107

Kia Rio

74.4%


Industry average77.6%

As you can see, the worst-rated car in the whole JD Power survey is the Chevrolet Spark, scoring just 70.2% on the satisfaction scale, against the average rating of 77.6%. The other four cars in the bottom five are the Alfa Romeo MiTo (70.7%), Fiat Grande Punto/Punto Evo (72.0%), Ford Ka (72.2%) and Fiat Panda (73.7%).

Surprisingly, BMW has one car in this list of clunkers: the BMW X1, the baby SUV (sports utility vehicle) introduced in October 2009.


The ten worst car brands

As well as rating customer satisfaction by individual car model, JD Power also produces a list of the best and worst makes overall. Here are the bottom ten manufacturers:

Ranking

Car maker

Percentage

score

27

Chevrolet

69.1%

26

Alfa Romeo

72.5%

25

Mitsubishi

74.5%

24

Peugeot

75.0%

23

Fiat

75.4%

22

Vauxhall

75.6%

21

Suzuki

75.8%

20

Mazda

76.2%

19

Renault

76.6%

18

Ford

77.1%


Industry average77.6%

As well as coming last in the car category, US manufacturer Chevrolet comes bottom of the brands, with a score of just 69.1%, versus the industry average of 77.6%. Other bad brands to own in the bottom five are Alfa Romeo (72.5%), Mitsubishi (74.5%), Peugeot (75%) and Fiat (75.4%).

The other members of this Hall of Shame are Vauxhall (75.6%), Suzuki (75.8%), Mazda (76.2%), Renault (76.6%) and Ford (77.1%). Then again, Ford and Vauxhall are the two biggest-selling car brands in the UK, so are likely to have millions of satisfied customers, as well plenty of critics.


One warning about this survey

Although this is the most comprehensive yearly ownership study in the UK, it does have one minor flaw. All it takes for a vehicle to be included in this survey is 50 completed questionnaires from owners. For the least-sold models, one single survey could change the final percentage score by as much as 2%.

As a result a couple of disgruntled drivers could send a particular model plummeting down the rankings. That's why I'd like to see JD Power list the number of surveys alongside each ranking, as this would for improve the clarity and transparency of its research.

[Earn money back on your fuel spending with a cashback credit card]


The best cars to own

Finally, for those of you looking to replace your vehicle in future and keen to avoid the clunkers, here are the 11 highest-rated cars featured in JD Power's 2013 UK survey:

Ranking

Car model

Percentage

score

1

Skoda Superb

83.0%

2

Skoda Yeti

82.8%

3

Jaguar XF

82.7%

4=

Citroën DS3

82.2%

4=

Lexus RX

82.2%

6=

Honda Jazz

82.0%

6=

Volkswagen Passat CC

82.0%

8

Volvo S60/V60

81.9%

9=

Lexus IS

81.4%

9=

Mercedes-Benz B-Class

81.4%

9=

Toyota Prius

81.4%


Industry average77.6%

*Thanks to three cars tied in ninth place, this table has 11 members instead of the usual 10.

Volkswagen-owned manufacturer Skoda takes the top two spots, scoring 83% and 82.8% for its Superb and Yeti models respectively. Jaguar continues its recent comeback, winning a score of 82.7% for the new XF range. The Citroën DS3 and Lexus RX round off the top five, both scoring 82.2%.

Finally, among the top-rated brands, Jaguar took top spot for the second year in a row, scoring 82.7%. Lexus scored 81.8% to take second place, with Honda (81.0%), Skoda (80.9%) and Mercedes-Benz (80.4%) completing the five top-rated manufacturers. Land Rover is also on the up, leaping six places to take sixth place and entering the top 10 for the first time.

[Can you save money on your car insurance? Take our comparison centre for a test drive]

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Latest Reviews

  • First Drive: McLaren 650S Spider
    First Drive: McLaren 650S Spider

    McLaren 650S What’s new?The 650S is essentially an evolution of the 12C, but with such a comprehensive spectrum of upgrades that symbolically it’s more like a brand new … More »First Drive: McLaren 650S Spider

    First Drive: McLaren 650S Spider

    McLaren 650S What’s new?The 650S is essentially an evolution of the 12C, but with such a comprehensive spectrum of upgrades that symbolically it’s more like a brand new car. Its mighty turbocharged V8 engine now has the sort of power you only used to get in unobtanium-rare hypercars, and the fact that the 650S is half a …

  • First Drive: Mercedes-Benz GLA
    First Drive: Mercedes-Benz GLA

    This is the smallest Mercedes-Benz with any kind of off-road leanings, and arguably it’s also the first proper crossover from the German firm. More »First Drive: Mercedes-Benz GLA

    First Drive: Mercedes-Benz GLA

    This is the smallest Mercedes-Benz with any kind of off-road leanings, and arguably it’s also the first proper crossover from the German firm.